Annabelle Ewing Calls for HGV Speed Limiters on Scenic Ochil Routes

Heavy goods vehicles are essential to local shops, farms, builders and manufacturers, but their size and stopping distance create particular risks on winding roads. Annabelle Ewing calls for properly tested speed-limiting measures for HGVs on selected scenic routes through Ochil, including the Hill of Tarvit, Muckhart and Auchterarder approaches. The proposal would build on existing vehicle limiters by applying lower, location-specific speeds where the hazards justify them.

As the Scottish National Party’s candidate for Ochil and South Perthshire, Ewing connects safer roads with Scottish independence, economic recovery and stronger representation at Westminster. Her legal career and previous parliamentary service give her experience of turning local concerns into practical legislation that communities can scrutinise and improve.

Why winding roads need a different approach

Ochil’s steep gradients, blind bends, narrow stretches and limited passing places leave little room for error. Drivers may encounter cyclists, pedestrians, farm vehicles or parked cars with little warning. Wet leaves, ice and low winter sunlight can make a familiar route suddenly unpredictable, while heavy vehicles need much more space to turn and stop safely.

Australian readers know the left-hand traffic pattern shared with Scotland, but not the units: Scottish speed limits appear in miles per hour, while Australian roads generally use kilometres per hour. Across Australia, many rural highways are signed at 100 or 110 km/h, depending on the state and route. Those comparisons demonstrate why clear signs, accurate vehicle displays and consistent enforcement would be essential.

A practical, phased safety policy

Ewing’s approach should begin with a mapped pilot using approved, location-aware speed assistance or equivalent technology. Suitable HGVs could receive a lower cap through defined zones, supported by advance signs, driver alerts and enforcement backed by recorded vehicle data. Emergency services, agricultural contractors and other essential users should be consulted rather than treated as afterthoughts.

The economic consequences must be considered alongside safety. Melbourne’s port and distribution network sends heavy vehicles along major routes including the M1 and M80, while Sydney uses curfews and delivery windows to manage traffic in tightly constrained streets. Australian hauliers understand the commercial value of predictable journey times. A Scottish pilot should therefore give operators clear routes, reasonable implementation periods and a reliable appeals process.

Approach Main benefit Practical limitation
Existing maximum-speed limiter Provides a consistent upper cap May not reflect local bends or hazards
Location-aware speed assistance Applies lower speeds in mapped areas Requires equipment, mapping and maintenance
Lower signed speed limit Is visible and easy to understand Affects every vehicle using the road
Targeted enforcement and education Addresses dangerous driving directly Depends on reliable evidence and consistent application

Evidence, enforcement and fairness

The pilot should publish its criteria and results, including collision data, reported near misses, compliance levels and freight disruption. Route selection should account for gradient, road width, visibility, lay-bys and pedestrian activity. Community residents, drivers, haulage businesses and emergency services should have a formal role in deciding whether each zone produces meaningful safety gains.

The campaign’s wider approach can be informed by broader road-safety evidence, working alongside driver rest rules, vehicle checks and safer stopping places. Queensland’s road trains and remote freight routes demonstrate why fatigue management matters wherever heavy vehicles travel long distances. In Ochil, enforcement should target unsafe behaviour without unfairly penalising foreign or small independent operators who have not been warned about a new control.

Local voices and economic recovery

Local businesses need predictable access, but residents also need roads that feel safe for walking, cycling and family journeys. A serious safety policy should not portray freight drivers as enemies of the countryside. It should recognise their economic contribution while creating sensible limits where heavy vehicles create the greatest risk.

The Adelaide Hills offer a useful Australian comparison: regional freight, winery deliveries and seasonal visitors share attractive but constrained roads. Australian road-trip culture expects regional areas to remain accessible while safety controls are visible and proportionate. Applying that principle in Ochil would protect tourism without shutting businesses out, supporting the recovery of local high streets and visitor destinations.

Independence, recovery and Westminster representation

Independence would give Scotland greater control over transport policy, infrastructure and enforcement, allowing rules for scenic routes to reflect local geography rather than being designed solely elsewhere. Ewing’s campaign presents that democratic control as part of a wider economic recovery based on investment, stronger public services and accountable government. Westminster representation remains important for the powers still reserved to the UK Parliament, including trade and funding.

Ewing served as the MP for Ochil and South Perthshire from 2015 to 2019 and previously practised as a lawyer. That background is relevant to a policy requiring clear legal authority, proportionate penalties and proper scrutiny. Her campaign combines a local case about dangerous heavy-vehicle routes with the larger SNP commitment to represent Scotland at Westminster and secure a more prosperous country.

Back safer Ochil roads and Scotland’s future

Supporters can back a practical speed-limiter pilot, share collision or near-miss evidence, and encourage local businesses and councils to participate in the consultation. Joining campaign updates or contacting the campaign team can help Ewing identify the routes where action is most urgent and the operators who need support. Local campaigning should turn concern about dangerous HGV movements into a policy that residents can see, test and enforce.

Anyone eligible and registered to vote in Ochil and South Perthshire should check the official electoral information, register if needed and apply for a postal vote where appropriate. Australians following the campaign can share Ewing’s proposals, but cannot vote in a Scottish election unless registered for a relevant British constituency. Back safer routes, bring local evidence and help Annabelle Ewing put both community safety and Scotland’s future on the ballot.